Skip to content

Are Your Enamel Inside-Out or Outdoors-In? – The Bristol Dinosaur Challenge


    Visitor Writer – Sophie Pollard
    Present Palaeobiology MSc Pupil

    Enamel, or at the very least tooth-like buildings, might be present in each jawed vertebrate group dwelling at present, and it’s uncommon to search out any lineage which has misplaced them fully. There is no such thing as a doubt that tooth have been a key growth in vertebrate evolutionary historical past, however the place did they arrive from within the first place?

    The reply is way more sophisticated than you may count on!

    What are the arguments?

    Fashions for the origin of tooth usually boil down to 2 arguments: outside-in, and inside-out. The skin-in speculation originated within the 19th century when researchers began to note the similarities between the buildings of tooth and dermal denticles (the robust scales which make up the pores and skin of sharks and rays).

    Each tooth and dermal denticles might be known as “odontodes”, a construction consisting of dentine with a hyper-mineralised cap of enamel or enameloid, each of which relaxation on a bone base for attachment. This similarity led to the idea that tooth are merely specialised scales that migrated inside our fishy ancestors’ mouths some 500 million years in the past.

    This concept was largely unchallenged till the mid-90s, as proof began to mount for an alternate speculation, turning outside-in, inside-out. The brand new, “inside-out” mannequin, urged that tooth developed a number of totally different occasions, originating contained in the pharynx of historic vertebrates fully independently of scales.

    No “lacking hyperlink”, dwelling or fossil, has ever been discovered displaying dermal odontodes extending into the oral cavity, so there isn’t a sure-fire option to show or disprove both argument, however we are able to make some observations.

    Trying on the fossils

    It’s clear from the fossil file that dermal denticles appeared earlier than jaws. Many ostracoderm teams had dermal odontodes. Ostracoderms aren’t a phylogenetic group, however an unofficial title for the numerous teams of extensively armoured jawless vertebrates that are associated to the primary jawed vertebrates.

    A phylogeny showing the distribution of skin & oral denticles and tooth-like structures in vertebrates.
    The distribution of pores and skin denticles, oral denticles and tooth-like buildings in vertebrates (Donoghue and Rücklin, 2016)

    Nonetheless, the inside-out speculation considers this commentary irrelevant, because it claims that the origin of tooth predated each dermal scales and jaws.

    Conodonts (an extinct group of jawless vertebrates thought to have diverged from the lineage resulting in jawed vertebrates extra just lately than fashionable jawless vertebrates) had tooth-like buildings, and so did the extinct thelodont, Loganellia.


    An image of conodont tooth structures next to a reconstruction of a conodont. Next to it is a fossil of a thelodont with a reconstruction of the animal.
    Left: Conodont reconstruction (Credit score to the Tree of Life Internet Challenge). Proper: The Thelodont species Loganellia (Thelodont refers to a category of extinct Palaeozoic jawless fishes which had distinctive scales versus plates).

    So, tooth got here earlier than each jaws and scales? Properly, as regular, we’ve got to take the proof with a grain of salt. There is no such thing as a option to inform if the tooth-like buildings in each of those circumstances are literally homologous to tooth, or in the event that they merely look the half, and don’t have anything to do with true tooth.

    Enamel in placoderms

    Placoderms make up a sister clade to fashionable chondrichthyans (cartilaginous fishes similar to sharks and rays) and Osteichthyans (bony fishes), and in some circumstances, possess tooth, making them vital to the outside-in/inside-out debate.

    Many arthrodirans (a very derived group of placoderms together with Dunkleosteus) had tooth, though there may be debate over whether or not these are true tooth as they lacked an enameloid cap.

    A mounted skull of the extinct placoderm Dunkleosteus
    A Dunkleosteus specimen at present housed within the Vienna Pure Historical past Museum.

    The within-out argument means that these buildings aren’t homologous to tooth, and are only one instance of the numerous occasions tooth have developed throughout totally different lineages, citing the shortage of tooth buildings in earlier, much less derived placoderms as proof.

    This isn’t the case, nevertheless, for Romundina, a much less derived acanthothoracid placoderm which lived within the early Devonian shallow seas. Not solely did Romundina have tooth, however these tooth had enameloid caps, suggesting that arthrodire tooth really be homologous to true tooth having misplaced this enameloid cap reasonably than creating independently.

    A reconstruction of the placoderm Romundina
    Reconstruction of the placoderm, Romundina, from the early Devonian of Canada.

    We all know that Outdoors-In is feasible

    A paper revealed in April 2022 lent a little bit extra assist to outdoors in, by confirming that dermal scales are fully able to creating the sort of advanced construction that we see in tooth.

    It regarded on the rostral denticles (the spikes you see on the elongated snout of a sawfish or sawsharks) of Ischyrhiza mira, an extinct ray (with an look way more much like at present’s sawfish) from the late Cretaceous, which might have lived in shallow coastal waters and grown as much as about two meters.

    A reconstruction of Onchopristis
    A reconstruction of Onchopristis, a detailed relative of I. mira.

    Regardless of being specialised physique scales, scanning electron microscopy revealed that the enameloid of I. mira’s rostral denticles was way more intricate than anticipated, and carefully resembles that present in shark tooth. The construction offers an additional degree of hardness to the odontode construction, which might have been helpful for foraging and self-defence within the case of I. mira.

    Rostral denticles of I. mira.
    Rostral denticles of I. mira, housed at Rutgers College Geology Museum.

    Though it doesn’t give any conclusive proof for the talk, this denticle construction lends lots of assist to the plausibility of the outside-in speculation, displaying that it’s potential for exterior odontodes to type a posh, tooth-like construction, which can have later migrated into the mouths of early vertebrates.

    Germ Layers

    The usage of germ layers is a brand new addition to the talk. The tissue forming the exterior epithelium (pores and skin) is derived from ectoderm while the epithelial lining of the digestive tract is derived from ectoderm. We all know that scales require ectoderm-derived epithelium as a way to develop, so it stands to purpose that if we work out what sort of epithelium cells tooth are rising on, we are able to work out the place they got here from. Simple proper?

    Properly, research are fairly conclusive on one fundamental conclusion: that the epithelium from which tooth develop can have an origin which is ectodermal, endodermal or a mix of the 2. So, whether or not the cells of an space are derived from ectoderm or endoderm in all probability doesn’t matter in any respect, at the very least within the few species for which we’ve got knowledge (most of what we’ve got is predicated on animals that are best to maintain in a lab, not essentially the perfect analogy for early vertebrates).

    That knowledge does present, nevertheless, that the interplay between cells derived from the 2 layers tends to happen throughout tooth growth, albeit with the floor layer at all times taking up ectodermal traits.

    The place can we go from right here?

    Except a fossil miraculously turns as much as give us all of the solutions, it’s unlikely that we’ll ever have a agency clarification for the origin of tooth, however there are issues we are able to do to get just a bit bit nearer to at least one.

    There is no such thing as a dwelling creature shut sufficient to the primary tooth-possessing vertebrates to precisely symbolize them in a research of germ layers, however the pattern dimension for these research may at all times stand to get quite a bit wider. Possibly a little bit (or extra doubtless quite a bit) extra perception into the germ layer contribution to tooth growth may paint us a clearer image of the place our dental historical past started.

    A cartoon of a parent and child sawfish over a basin. The child is holding a toothbrush. The caption reads "Now the left side..."
    Picture credit score to Dom Pollard

    Sophie Pollard is a present Palaeobiology MSc pupil on the College of Bristol.

    Article edited by Rhys Charles


    Prepare dinner, T.D. et al. (2022) Advanced enameloid microstructure of Ischyrhiza mira rostral denticles. Journal of Anatomy. 241: 616 – 627

    Donoghue, P.C.J., & Rücklin, M. (2016) The ins and outs of the evolutionary origin of tooth. Evolution & Growth. 18: 19 – 30

    Huysseune, A., Cerny, R., & Witten, P.E. (2022) The conundrum of pharyngeal tooth origin: the function of germ layers, pouches, and gill slits. Organic Evaluations. 97: 414 – 447

    Rücklin, M. et al. (2012) Growth of tooth and jaws within the earliest jawed vertebrates. Nature. 491: 748-751

    Rücklin, M., & Donoghue, P.C.J. (2015) Romundina and the evolutionary origin of tooth. Biology Letters. 11: 20150326