Skip to content

Open Farm vs. Stella & Chewy’s Canine Meals 2022 Comparability:  Which One Is Higher?


    open farm vs stella and chewy3

    With so many choices out there in pet food, it may be exhausting to know which one is best for you. This comparability will spotlight the variations between Open Farm and Stella and Chewy’s pet food. Each corporations have kibble, moist meals, and freeze-dried uncooked meals. They each use high-quality substances and provide subscription supply providers. So, what makes one higher than the opposite? Let’s discover out!

    Divider 8

    A Sneak Peek on the Winner: Open Farm

    Open Farm affords all kinds of recipe decisions, various kinds of pet food, and an inexpensive subscription pet food service for its prospects. If you’re searching for transparency concerning substances and sourcing, Open Farm is an open e-book. They provide distinctive customer support and distinctive decisions on your canine’s eating regimen.

    Listed here are our two favourite Open Farm recipes:

    Score Picture Product Particulars

    Our Favourite


    Open Farm Turkey & Chicken

    Open Farm Turkey & Rooster

  • Actual meat is the primary ingredient

  • Low-fat content material

  • Applicable for all life levels
  • Second place

    Open Farm Freeze-Dried Surf n Turf

    Open Farm Freeze-Dried Surf n Turf

  • Excessive in natural substances

  • Excessive protein content material

  • Personalized portion sizes
  • About Open Farm

    Open Farm is a family-owned and -operated firm primarily based in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The corporate’s founders wished to develop pet meals that was top quality and constructed from ethically sourced substances. The corporate prides itself on offering full transparency about its substances, sourcing practices, and influence on the surroundings.

    Open Farm manufactures high-quality, uncooked, moist, dry, and recent meals. Every is made with a special protein as the principle ingredient, and there’s a large number of recipe decisions for every kind of meals.

    • Household-owned and operated

    • Prides itself on moral sourcing of substances

    • Clear about manufacturing processes

    • Good customer support

    • Simple to customise subscription service

    • A lot of recipe decisions
    • Solely out there by a subscription service
    • Not very many single-protein recipes
    • The minimal selection for puppies and senior canines

    About Stella and Chewy’s

    Stella and Chewy’s origin is just like that of Open Farm. The corporate’s founder, Marie Moody, developed a ardour for pet diet after recovering an ailing rescue canine. The need of feeding this canine a uncooked eating regimen led her to seek out a neater manner for pet mother and father to feed their canines extremely nutritious, high quality meals with out the extreme quantity of effort and time required to make their very own.

    Whereas Stella and Chewy’s began as an completely raw-food firm, it has since expanded its pet meals strains to incorporate a wide range of totally different choices and recipes.

    Stella and Chewy’s frozen and freeze-dried uncooked meals are made in Oak Creek, Wisconsin. They’re made utilizing a 100% pure antimicrobial course of to inactivate any pathogens in recent meals. The supply of the substances is unclear, nonetheless. The one info out there concerning sourcing is that they’re obtained from “trusted” companions. Whereas this doesn’t indicate a scarcity of sustainably sourced, high-quality substances, it does increase questions on the place they arrive from.

    • Deal with high-quality diet

    • No components or preservatives

    • Deal with recent meals

    • Meat is the primary ingredient in all recipes

    • Added dietary supplements
    • Lack of awareness about ingredient sourcing
    • Lack of dry and moist meals choices

    Divider 4

    3 Most Common Open Farm Canine Meals Recipes

    1. Open Farm Homestead Turkey

    Open Farm Homestead Turkey

    Open Farm’s Homestead Turkey and Rooster dry pet food incorporates actual meat within the prime three substances. It’s a low-fat meals at 30%, making it a great choice for canines which have issue sustaining a wholesome weight. DHA is added to this recipe to advertise mind well being and cognitive growth. The kibble is small, so this meals is suitable for canines of all sizes.

    Since this recipe incorporates each hen and turkey, it’s not appropriate for canines with protein sensitivities. Additionally it is fairly costly in comparison with different dry pet food manufacturers.

    • Actual meat is the primary ingredient

    • Low-fat content material

    • Applicable for all life levels

    • Small kibble

    • Dietary supplements added to advertise cognitive well being
    • Two protein substances
    • Costly

    2. Open Farm Surf & Turf Freeze-Dried Uncooked Canine Meals

    Open Farm Freeze-Dried Surf n turf

    Open Farm’s Surf and Turf Freeze-Dried Uncooked recipe affords a excessive amount of natural meats mixed with natural vegetables and fruit. This recipe has a protein content material of 41% and a fats content material of 32.5%. This meals is tasty for canines however costly in comparison with many different dry meals.

    Open Farm Surf and Turf may be bought in baggage as much as 22 oz. in measurement. You dole out every portion of your canine’s meals and set your auto-ship schedule based on how a lot you want. This supplies good worth on your cash and creates much less waste total.

    • Excessive in natural substances

    • Excessive protein content material

    • Personalized portion sizes

    • Customizable auto-ship subscription

    • Good worth for the cash
    • Costlier than dry or moist meals
    • Solely out there on-line
    • Requires freezer or fridge storage

    3. Open Farm Gently Cooked Homestead Turkey

    Open Farm Gently Cooked Turkey

    The gently cooked Homestead Turkey Recipe from Open Farm affords high quality recent meals on your canine. This meals incorporates a single protein supply, so it’s a good selection for canines with meals sensitivities. The ingredient listing is clear and stuffed with superfood substances to supply optimum diet.

    This Open Farms recipe is offered in pre-packaged parts for recent meals that opens, thaws, and feeds. It’s shipped frozen to keep away from spoilage, however you have to freezer area to retailer the meals. The Homestead Turkey cooked recipe may be served as a meal or as a topper to dry meals.

    • Single protein supply

    • Sensible choice for canines with meals sensitivities

    • Quick substances listing

    • Added superfood substances for optimum diet

    • Avoids the danger of feeding uncooked meals

    • Pre-packaged parts

    • Use as a full meal or topper
    • Requires freezer area
    • Have to be thawed previous to feeding

    Divider 3

    3 Most Common Stella and Chewy’s Canine Meals Recipes

    1. Stella and Chewy’s Rooster and Historic Grains

    Stella & Chewy's Essentials Chicken

    Stella and Chewy’s Rooster and Historic Grains recipe is a part of its healthful grain kibble line. The primary ingredient is actual meat, and the meals is pea, lentil, and potato free. It’s full of added dietary supplements like omega fatty acids, glucosamine, chondroitin, and taurine. This recipe has a protein stage of 25% with a low-fat content material of 15%. This meals is appropriate for all life levels.

    The manufacturing course of utilized by Stella and Chewy’s for his or her dry kibble recipes ensures that the dietary high quality of the unique substances is maintained. Sadly, this additionally makes the meals dearer than different kibble choices.

    • The primary ingredient is meat

    • Low-fat content material

    • Single protein ingredient

    • Added dietary supplements to advertise total well being

    • Appropriate for all life levels
    • Costlier than different kibble choices

    2. Stella and Chewy’s Duck Duck Goose Dinner Patties

    Stella & Chewy's Duck Duck Goose Freeze-Dried

    Stella and Chewy’s Duck Duck Goose Dinner Patties are constructed from 95% uncooked poultry, organs, and bone. That is rounded out with a mixture of natural vegetables and fruit. Taurine, probiotics, and antioxidants are included to spherical out the dietary profile. Protein and fats ranges are 38% and 32.5%, respectively. The type of this meals makes portioning comparatively straightforward. Nonetheless, it additionally makes Stella and Chewy’s uncooked meals costly. It affords much less worth for the cash than Open Farm, which is available in massive batches and extra customizable portion sizes.

    Stella and Chewy’s patties are small. A 40-pound canine would require roughly 10 patties per day if this meals made up their entire eating regimen. A 100-pound canine would require 19 patties.

    • Implausible dietary profile

    • High quality substances

    • Added nutritional vitamins and minerals

    • Handy patty type

    3. Stella and Chewy’s Gobblin’ Good Gently Cooked Turkey Recipe

    Stella & Chewy's Fresh Made Gobblin Good

    The Gobblin’ Good gently cooked frozen meals recipe from Stella and Chewy’s seems remarkably just like the Homestead Turkey from Open Farm. The ingredient listing is nearly similar, and the meals affords your canine a protein-rich, low-carb choice. The protein content material is barely increased for Stella and Chewy’s.

    This meals is delivered in pre-packaged parts of recent meals that you simply open, thaw, and feed to your canine.

    • Single protein supply applicable for meals sensitivities

    • Keep away from the danger of contamination from dealing with uncooked meals

    • High quality dietary profile

    • Low carbohydrate choice

    • Excessive protein content material

    • Pre-packaged parts

    Recall the Historical past of Open Farm and Stella and Chewy’s

    Our analysis exhibits that there have been no recollects on Open Farm pet meals. Stella and Chewy’s have had two recollects, each for Listeria contamination. The corporate issued voluntary recollects of affected meals each instances.

    Open Farm vs Stella and Chewy’s Comparability

    Open Farm and Stella and Chewy’s each provide high quality, nutritious pet food. How do the businesses themselves evaluate?


    Edge: Stella and Chewy’s

    Stella and Chewy’s pet food is less complicated to seek out than Open Farm. It’s out there to order from a number of in style on-line retailers, the corporate itself, and a number of pet shops. Open Farm has extra restricted availability. Whereas it’s bought in some shops, it’s tough to seek out outdoors of on-line ordering.

    Dietary High quality

    Edge: Tie

    Open Farm and Stella and Chewy’s each provide high-quality, sustainably sourced, nutritious pet food. You may’t go incorrect with both one.


    Edge: Open Farm

    Open Farm affords a extra economical choice for shoppers, notably its dry pet food recipes. Stella and Chewy’s dry meals is dearer and is probably not applicable for canine house owners on a finances.

    Whereas the worth of dry pet food is considerably decrease with Open Farm, Stella and Chewy’s affords extra inexpensive moist meals.


    Edge: Open Farm

    Open Farm affords a wide selection of merchandise to select from for canines. These embody dry recipes, moist meals, gently cooked recent meals, freeze-dried uncooked meals, treats, toppers, and dietary supplements.

    Stella and Chewy’s have lots of the similar choices, however they’re primarily recognized for his or her freeze-dried uncooked meals. They do promote dry and moist meals, however there may be much less recipe choice than Open Farm.


    Edge: Open Farm

    Open Farm has extra recipe decisions and extra inexpensive choices, and they’re extra clear about their substances than Stella and Chewy’s. Open Farm has additionally by no means been recalled, whereas Stella and Chewy’s meals has been recalled twice.

    Divider 7


    If you’re searching for high quality, nutritious meals on your canine, each Open Farm and Stella and Chewy’s present this. They use high quality substances and place your canine’s well being first when growing their recipes. Each provide a number of novel protein and limited-ingredient recipes, in addition to age-specific formulation. Nonetheless, Open Farm comes out because the winner over Stella and Chewy’s. Its meals is extra inexpensive, it’s extra clear about its ingredient sourcing, and its merchandise have by no means been recalled. Whereas Open Farm pet food isn’t as straightforward to seek out on retailer cabinets, it has a user-friendly web site the place you possibly can join an auto-ship subscription service. These elements make us advocate Open Farm as the higher selection over Stella and Chewy’s.