Skip to content

Ought to Your Canine Put on a Harness or a Collar? Right here Are the Professionals and Cons


    November 10, 2021

    DJANGO Dog Blog - Should Your Dog Wear a Harness or a Collar? Here Are the Pros and Cons of Each Leash Attachment Type -

    Canine collars and harnesses are an extremely essential a part of canine possession and canine care. They allow you to stroll your canine on a leash with safety and provide you with a spot to hold your canine’s vaccination and ID tags.

    Are you bringing residence your first pet and not sure whether or not to buy a canine collar or canine harness? Or are you an skilled canine proprietor who merely needs to higher perceive the rationale between selecting a collar vs. harness? It’s vital to know the professionals and cons of each earlier than choosing one or the opposite in your canine.

    On this DJANGO Canine Weblog article, Mike and I (Steph) will assist you determine which gear it is best to use primarily based on your canine’s breed, exercise stage, and life-style. 



    Canine harnesses take stress off your canine’s again and neck: As a result of harnesses fasten on the again or chest, they don’t put stress in your canine’s trachea (extra on that under). That is ideally suited if your canine has or is susceptible to neck issues, a collapsing windpipe, or blocked airways. It could possibly additionally assist stop these well being issues from taking place.

    Canine harnesses improve the walker’s and canine’s consolation: Uninterested in tug-o-war walks that finish with sore, purple palms and achy joints? Think about using a back-clip canine harness. It evenly applies stress over a bigger floor space of your canine’s physique, supplying you with extra management over your rambunctious pet or large canine, and enhancing your canine’s consolation as he walks, runs, and performs.

    Some canine harnesses discourage pulling: To stop pulling, think about a front-clip (aka “no pull”) canine harness. When your canine pulls on his leash, it should pressure him to show to the aspect, so he won’t be able to go ahead till he slows down.

    Canine harnesses are safer than collars: Canines can wiggle out of their collars and probably run into the road or get right into a canine battle. As a result of a top quality canine harness securely fastens round your pup’s physique, it’s usually thought of safer and safer.

    Canine harnesses are good coaching instruments for puppies: Puppies will tug and chunk their leashes as a result of they’re bored or immature. If puppies are excited, in addition they could wrap their leashes round their homeowners or get caught in them. Leashes can get twisted round their neck or leg and lower off their blood circulation. A back-clip harness can preserve puppies and grownup canines from getting tangled of their leashes. It additionally protects the individuals who must untangle them from being scratched or bitten.

    Example of a high quality dog harness


    Canine harnesses will not be as handy: Canine collars simply slip on and off, however canine harnesses usually have a number of buckles and straps which might be extra difficult to lock. Search for a canine harness that’s particularly designed for straightforward on and off, like this one.

    Some canine harnesses could be uncomfortable: Harnesses are naturally heavier than collars. Canines not used to harnesses could dislike having them slipped over their heads. Pups with arthritis will not be snug having a leg lifted right into a harness strap. You will need to get a top quality canine harness that matches your canine’s particular wants.

    For canines that don’t like having a harness slipped over their head, think about a step-in canine harness. Because the title suggests, canines can step into these harnesses with their entrance paws they usually fasten within the again. For senior canines with arthritis that can’t elevate their legs with out discomfort, ensure that to get a harness with twin side-release buckles on the chest strap. This may mean you can safe the harness round your pup’s physique with out her or him having to elevate their legs.

    Some canine harnesses could cause chafing: In case your pup’s harness is poorly designed, too tight, or worn improperly, it will possibly rub the pores and skin round his armpits and elbows. For that reason, you will need to choose a high quality canine harness that’s padded, light-weight, and deliberately designed to forestall chafing of any type. When you’ve got a rambunctious and lively canine (like our sausage canine Django!), grime and particles may also construct up on the harness over time and trigger discomfort. To stop this from taking place, merely wash your canine’s harness a minimum of as soon as a month.

    No-pull harnesses could alter your pup’s pure gait: No-pull canine harnesses  could make it onerous in your canine to maneuver his shoulders. They’ll additionally change how he naturally walks. Even when your canine’s harness will not be connected to a leash, he’ll carry much less weight on his entrance legs. He may also put extra weight on the entrance leg that’s beside you. 


    When you’ve got a senior canine and/or long-bodied canine breed in danger for intervertebral disc illness (IVDD): Canines which might be low to the bottom like basset hounds, dachshunds, and Welsh Pembroke corgis are susceptible to intervertebral disc illness (IVDD). IVDD happens when a disc in your pup’s backbone bulges or bursts. The slipped disk leaks fluid that pushes in opposition to his spinal wire and nerves. It causes neck and again ache, muscle spasms, wobbling and incoordination, and rear-limb paralysis. To assist stop additional harm, think about using a harness to take stress off your canine’s neck and backbone.

    When you’ve got a small canine breed that’s vulnerable to tracheal collapse: Tracheal collapse impacts the trachea, or windpipe, and the decrease airway, the place giant tubes referred to as mainstem bronchi carry air to the lungs. The windpipe connects the lungs to the nostril and mouth and is lined with rings of agency white tissue referred to as cartilage. If the rings of cartilage turn out to be weak and versatile, they are going to flatten when your canine breathes in. This causes a continuing, dry, harsh cough, wheezing, and gagging.

    Chihuahuas, Lhasa apsos, Pomeranians, Shih Tzus, toy poodles, and Yorkshire terriers are most in danger for tracheal collapse. Chubby and senior canines even have the next danger of creating the illness. Whereas huge, comfortable canine collars trigger much less harm than tougher thinner collars, harnesses don’t put any stress in your canine’s windpipe.

    In case your canine is a brachycephalic breed: Flat-faced canine breeds, like French bulldogs, Boston terriers, and pugs, have brief, pushed-in noses and shallow eye sockets. In the event that they pull too onerous on the leash connected to their collars, their eyes could utterly or partially come out of their heads. That is referred to as ocular proptosis, and it mostly impacts Brussels griffons and Pekinese. Brachys even have narrower windpipes and smaller nostrils. And so they have a big flap of additional pores and skin behind their throats. For that reason, it’s endorsed that snub-nosed canine breeds solely put on a harness when on a leash.

    When you’ve got an older canine with well being issues: Senior canines which have arthritis or hip dysplasia have a tough time getting up or mendacity down. Harnesses may help you hoist them up with out inflicting further discomfort and ache.

    The pros of high quality dog harnesses



    Canine collars are extra handy: Collars can sometimes be worn always whereas harnesses ought to solely be worn if you find yourself happening a stroll. Even should you select to take away your pup’s collar at evening to provide his pores and skin an opportunity to breathe, it’s nonetheless simpler to tackle and off than a harness.

    Collars are higher for canines with lipomas: Lipomas are non-cancerous tumors which might be made up of fats cells. They’re prevalent in senior canines which might be neutered or chubby. Any canine breed can develop fatty tumors. However they’re commonest in dachshunds, Shetland sheepdogs, Doberman pinschers, Labrador retrievers, German pointers, and Weimaraners. Harnesses could irritate or rub your canine’s fatty tumors, inflicting his pores and skin to turn out to be crusty, bloody, and/or swollen. 

    Collars are higher for canines after sure surgical procedures: Did your pup simply have preventative bloat surgical procedure? Emergency heartworm extraction surgical procedure? He could not be capable of put on a canine harness till he utterly recovers. A harness could rub his stitches and create friction blisters. If the friction blisters pop, they will decelerate the therapeutic course of. Think about educating your canine to put on a collar in case he ever wants torso surgical procedure.

    Canine collars maintain ID tags: Most top quality and excessive finish canine collars have devoted metallic or plastic identification attachment items the place you may connect your canine’s ID tag together with your title, bodily tackle, and telephone quantity in case he will get misplaced. In most states, in line with the ASPCA, the return-to-owner fee is 10%-30% for canines. An ID tag makes your pup extra approachable to strangers as a result of it signifies he’s not a feral or stray canine.

    The pros of dog collars -


    Canine collars can put stress in your canine’s windpipe. As talked about above, canine collars can put undue stress in your canine’s trachea. Keep away from collars and go for a top quality canine harness if your canine has or is susceptible to neck issues, a collapsing windpipe, or blocked airways.

    Canine collars could cause pores and skin issues: Too tight collars could cause chafing, discomfort, and hair loss. They’ll additionally lead to a gentle, purple rash round your canine’s neck that stings or burns. The pores and skin in that space can also be extra susceptible to fungal and bacterial infections. 

    Canine collars can turn out to be embedded in a rising pet’s neck. In gentle circumstances, the embedded canine collar will harm the highest layers of a pet’s pores and skin. In excessive circumstances, it should lower into his muscle mass and connective tissue, and his pores and skin will start to develop over his collar. If he spends a variety of time outdoor, flies might also give start to stay maggots or lay eggs in his wound. 

    Canine collars could cause strangulation: In case your canine’s collar will not be tight sufficient, he can snag it on a window latch or within the wires of his metallic crate. This will result in suffocation. Even when your canine is tied up within the yard, a well-fitting collar can nonetheless be harmful. In case your canine is on a protracted leash and tries to leap a fence, he might find yourself hanging himself along with his collar. 

    Canine collars could cause mouth or limb accidents: In case your canine’s collar is just too free, his tongue and enamel can get caught in it whereas he grooms himself. This will trigger damaged enamel and different mouth accidents. In case your canine scratches his ears along with his entrance or again leg, it’d get caught in his collar. If he struggles to free himself, he might break a limb. 


    Canine collars are sometimes ideally suited for big canine breeds with sturdy, muscular necks. They’re additionally acceptable as secondary canine equipment on small- and medium-sized canines that put on canine harnesses. Think about pairing your canine’s harness with an identical collar. Your pup can put on his harness and collar when he’s out strolling and adventuring, and merely put on his collar and ID tag at residence. 


    Should Your Dog Wear a Harness or a Collar? -

    In the event you’re searching for a top quality, sturdy, and trendy canine harness, think about DJANGO’s 5-star rated Journey Canine Harness. The neoprene exterior is waterproof, stain-resistant, and extremely simple to scrub. The padded, light-weight, and modern harness physique is formed to forestall any danger of chafing and maximize consolation regardless of how lengthy your outing or journey.

    DJANGO’s Journey Canine Collars options heavy-duty but tremendous comfortable webbing that’s light, comfortable, and versatile in opposition to your canine’s neck. Each DJANGO collar incorporates a heavy-duty ID tag attachment piece, a rust-resistant and high-strength stable forged brass D-ring for leash attachment, and a high-density branded buckle for straightforward on and off. It matches completely with our best-selling Journey Canine Harness, ergonomic and light-weight Commonplace Journey Canine Leash, and/or versatile and trendy Adjustable Arms-Free Journey Canine Leash.

    Go away a remark

    Feedback shall be accredited earlier than exhibiting up.